The Arnold House

4.6(462 reviews on Google)

Places to stay listing in Livingston Manor, NY

About The Arnold House

A 1900 farmhouse on Shandelee Mountain near Livingston Manor is home to The Arnold House, a hotel and tavern run by Sims Foster and Kirsten Harlow Foster. Sixteen guest rooms are spread across four buildings: the Main Building, the Garden House, Shandelee Post and Bobbie's Farmhouse. The Tavern serves wood-fired food, and the grounds hold a renovated dining room, a pole barn, a greenhouse, gardens and hiking trails. There is a pool, and some rooms are dog-friendly. Weddings, private events and corporate retreats are hosted here too. Rated 4.6 from 462 Google reviews, 357 of them five stars.

What reviewers mention: wedding venue (43), accommodating staff (23), greenhouse (19), barn (16), cozy spaces (8), fire pit (4), pool table (3), mulled wine (2), sitting by the fire (2), rustic decor (2)

Services and details

  • Overnight stay

    Yes

  • Pet friendly

    Yes

  • Pool

    Yes

  • Restaurant or bar

    Yes

No information yet on shuttle to Bethel Woods, sleeps 6 or more, hot tub, kitchen or kitchenette, breakfast included, lake or river access, eV charging, event-weekend minimum stay, tent sites, rV hookups, cabin or glamping. The website did not say; call and ask.

Contact

Listing compiled from public sources on 2026-10-14. Report a correction or request removal. Back to places to stay in Livingston Manor.